Allstate May Not Show It Ever Delivered a Copy of the Coverage | Property Insurance coverage Protection Legislation Weblog


How many individuals pay insurance coverage, 12 months after 12 months, and nothing occurs apart from paying premiums? This was the case for Eva Mallek. Then roughly 20 years after she bought the insurance coverage, she had a hearth. Allstate argued that no protection existed as a result of she was not residing on the residence when the hearth occurred. Mallet mentioned she by no means obtained a replica of the coverage and didn’t know of the requirement. 

Eva Mallet, who didn’t even file a short on the appellate court docket, gained. Allstate couldn’t show it ever delivered a replica of the coverage. The federal appellate court docket dominated for her and located:1

As to Allstate’s second substantive argument, the district court docket correctly granted abstract judgment to Mallek as a result of Allstate didn’t submit any proof on abstract judgment to rebut Mallek’s sworn testimony that Allstate didn’t present her a replica of the Commonplace Householders Coverage previous to her loss….Even contemplating Allstate’s response to the order to indicate trigger, it nonetheless didn’t submit any proof to ascertain a real dispute of fabric truth. Allstate asserted that it anticipated that one among its workers would testify at trial that, in response to Allstate’s enterprise data, the Commonplace Householders Coverage was mailed to Mallek in 1996. However Allstate didn’t submit an affidavit from its worker to assist that assertion….

I’m wondering if Allstate goes to promote the way it handled Eva Mallek so others can know what to anticipate in the event that they buy insurance coverage from Allstate. 

Thought For The Day

Promoting is legalized mendacity.

—H.G. Wells

1 Mallek v. Allstate Ins. Co., No 22-86, 2023 WL 3513783 (second Cir. Could 18, 2023).


Leave a Comment