Ought to Depreciation Be Taken on Partial Losses When Figuring out Precise Money Worth? | Property Insurance coverage Protection Legislation Weblog


The time period “precise money worth” is a nebulous time period. There are numerous disagreements about what it means. I counsel that’s the reason many states comply with the “broad proof rule,” which permits many measures to be thought of when figuring out the outcome.

Yesterday’s submit, Can a Policyholder Use Substitute Price Advantages to Transform or Exchange at One other Location? What’s the Customary to Acquire Substitute Price Advantages? The Three Prong Limitation, famous a previous submit, Substitute Price Implications by Changing at One other Location: Answering the Query if You Must Restore or Exchange on the Similar Premises to Get hold of the Holdback of Full Substitute Price Advantages. That earlier submit quoted some older instances indicating that depreciation shouldn’t be taken on partial losses when figuring out precise money worth. 

That is not true in lots of states. For instance, the Tennessee Supreme Courtroom clarified its rule, stating:1                 

We’re of the opinion that the motion of the Courtroom of Appeals in Third Nationwide Financial institution…doesn’t overrule, however, however, helps Newark Fireplace…particularly held that depreciation must be deducted from substitute price.

A fireplace insurance coverage contract is a contract of indemnity. Its objective is to reimburse the insured; to revive him as practically as potential to the place he was in earlier than the loss. The replacement-less-depreciation rule and the broad proof rule function to perform indemnity.

The appliance of a replacement-with-out-depreciation rule, as contended for by plaintiffs, would steadily reap a revenue for the insured, though it may end in a loss. Exhibit 3 to the criticism signifies that plaintiff Braddock’s roof was 15 years outdated on the time of loss and {that a} new roof would price $247.00.

Clearly, the ‘precise money worth’ of the outdated roof, which was 15 years outdated, will need to have been significantly lower than the price of a brand new one. If he ought to recuperate the price of a brand new roof, as contended for, he would have made a revenue on the loss. The ends of indemnity wouldn’t have been served. The query of whether or not Depreciation might be thought of in figuring out precise money worth was not a difficulty for determination by the Courtroom of Appeals in Third Nationwide Financial institution. As now we have above identified, it was correctly submitted to the jury together with all different components beneath correct directions which the Courtroom of Appeals authorised.

Policyholders and public adjusters ought to first learn the insurance coverage coverage for definitions and valuation guidelines concerning precise money worth. The relevant state regulation then must be thought of as a result of states have numerous guidelines that apply to the coverage language concerning precise money worth.

Thought For The Day     

The one approach to cope with ambiguity is to embrace it.

—Erich Fromm

1 Braddock v. Memphis Fireplace Ins. Corp., 493 S.W.2nd 453 (Tenn. 1973).


Leave a Comment