Which Pet Insurance coverage Is Greatest For You?


To maintain the lights on, we obtain affiliate commissions through a few of our hyperlinks. Our evaluate course of.

two dogs at the vet on exam table wearing lab coats laying down

Nationwide had essentially the most gross written premiums (GWP) for pet insurance coverage within the U.S. in 2022, with $860.6 million. Pets Greatest writes lower than half of Nationwide’s, with $365 million GWP.1 However simply because Nationwide has greater than double the quantity of GWP than Pets Greatest, that doesn’t essentially imply it’s higher.

Nationwide Pet Insurance coverage was born when the huge insurance coverage firm bought VPI, an organization that had been based in 1984 as the primary pet insurance coverage firm). On account of its longevity, it’s had 15 years or longer (relying on the corporate you might be evaluating it to) to accrue clients and a repute. Nonetheless, when Pets Greatest busted into the pet insurance coverage market in 2005, it created plenty of uproar, particularly because it was based by Dr. Jack Stephens, the exact same man who based VPI 21 years earlier! Providing a few of the lowest costs with complete protection obtained everybody’s consideration, and Pets Greatest shortly turned a well-liked alternative for many pet homeowners.

Our article compares Pets Greatest and Nationwide head-to-head, and we select a transparent winner. We clarify our reasoning together with every firm’s strengths and weaknesses that will help you higher perceive what every has to supply.

Go to Pets Greatest’s Web site | Go to Nationwide’s Web site

Coverage Protection

Dog under covers (caption: Policy Coverage Winner)

The desk beneath reveals what Pets Greatest and Nationwide cowl.

Be aware: Each firms cowl emergency care, surgical procedure and hospitalization, specialised exams and specialty care, X-rays, blood assessments, ultrasounds, cat scans, MRIs, rehabilitation, most cancers, continual circumstances, euthanasia, hereditary circumstances, congenital circumstances, non-routine dental therapy, and prescription medicines.

Neither covers pre-existing circumstances, cremation and burial prices, being pregnant and breeding, or pointless beauty procedures.

*Ready intervals for Maine are as follows:

  • Accidents – 0 days
  • Diseases – 14 days
  • Cruciate Ligament Circumstances – 30 days
  • Routine Care – 0 days

One of many key areas the place Pets Greatest and Nationwide differ is how their plans are arrange. Nationwide makes use of a profit schedule for a few of its plans, which outlines the utmost protection quantity you’ll be able to count on to be reimbursed for every situation. In the meantime, Pets Greatest’s plans are arrange like different insurers, the place the declare reimbursement relies in your vet invoice and the deductible, payout, and reimbursement share to your plan. Nationwide additionally presents some of these plans, however they arrive with restricted deductible and reimbursement share choices. Individuals who dwell in costlier areas like New York Metropolis or San Francisco would probably incur larger vet payments than somebody in a rural space in Iowa. So having a set profit schedule for all clients could make extra sense for pet homeowners who dwell in areas with a decrease value of residing.

One other vital protection issue is that Nationwide doesn’t enroll new pets after their tenth birthday. However, Pets Greatest enforces no most age restrictions for brand new pets.

Pets Best logo

Though Nationwide covers different/holistic remedy and examination charges at no additional value, we dock them for his or her profit schedule and most age restrictions. Due to this, Pets Greatest wins this class.

Coverage Protection Winner: Pets Greatest

Buyer Service & Fame

Person holding phone next to dog (caption: Customer Service Winner)

Pets Greatest’s greatest criticism is its lengthy declare processing instances at current. Pet mother and father are impressed with Pets Greatest’s thorough protection and decrease costs, which is why so many sign-up. Nonetheless, this ends in a big quantity of filed claims, overloading their system and delaying declare processing. Pets Greatest says they’re actively hiring and coaching extra folks to return to a extra aggressive declare processing timeline.

Pets Best logo

As for Nationwide, there are numerous complaints relating to reimbursement considerations, sudden renewal modifications, drastic premium will increase, and extra. Discovering destructive critiques isn’t tough for Nationwide, and so they’re associated to quite a few departments/considerations, which is why Pets Greatest wins this class.

Buyer Service & Fame Winner: Pets Greatest

Declare Processing

Doctor's office papers (caption: Claim Repayment Winner)

Pets Greatest averages 7-14 days for declare processing, which is longer than many others within the trade. Nonetheless, Pets Greatest additionally presents an choice to pay vets straight, so that you don’t have to attend for reimbursement. This can be an excellent choice for those who don’t need to wait to your declare to be processed. However be sure you verify your vet can work on this method earlier than you make any assumptions.

Nationwide averages 4 days for declare processing. That is shorter than Pets Greatest and plenty of different firms within the trade, which is why it wins this class.

Nationwide logo

Declare Processing Winner: Nationwide

Value Of Coverage

Dog laying next to money (caption: Pricing Winner)

Pets Greatest and Nationwide have no enrollment charges, however each cost a $2 month-to-month transaction charge until you pay your annual premium upfront annually.

Your premium worth quote relies in your pet’s particulars (age, breed, location, and so on.). We suggest acquiring quotes from every firm to your particular pet and evaluating protection to grasp the true worth you’d get for the worth. You too can go to our pet insurance coverage comparability quotes to see a couple of pattern costs we’ve gathered.

Evaluating costs for Pets Greatest and Nationwide is tough as a result of they don’t provide the identical plan varieties and choices (not an apples-to-apples comparability). In the event you go for Nationwide’s profit schedule plan, you’ll almost certainly see a decrease month-to-month premium than Pets Greatest. Nonetheless, for those who go for a traditional-style pet insurance coverage plan, costs for each firms typically fall across the identical worth level. Because of this we’ve declared this class a tie.

Value Of Coverage Winner: Pets Greatest & Nationwide (Tie)


Pets Greatest

Pets Greatest presents the next reductions:

  • 5% off for a number of pets
  • 5% off for army members and their households

Use this hyperlink to benefit from the absolute best worth. No promo code is required. You too can go to our devoted Pets Greatest promotions web page to be taught extra.


Nationwide Pet Insurance coverage presents the next reductions:

  • 5% off for 2-3 pets lined
  • 10% off for 4 or extra pets lined (could embrace exotics like birds, rabbits, and so on.)

No promo code is required. Use this hyperlink to benefit from the absolute best worth.

Plan Customization

Several types of dogs sitting together (caption: Customize Plan Winner)

Discovering an organization with the protection you want that matches your price range is essential. Look beneath to see what plan choices every of those suppliers provide.

Pets GreatestNationwide
Deductible Choices$50, $100, $200, $250, $500, $1,000$250
Payout Choices$5,000, LimitlessRestricted Per Situation, Limitless
Reimbursement Choices70%, 80%, 90%50%, 70%, 90%
Accident-Solely PlanBrown checkmark (Yes)Orange X (No or Not)
Pets Best logo

Pets Greatest has many customization choices to assist suit your protection to your wants and price range. However, Nationwide makes use of a profit schedule for some plans, which limits your customization choices. And for its different plans, Nationwide nonetheless has minimal customizations. Because of this Pets Greatest wins this class.

Plan Customization Winner: Pets Greatest

What’s The Verdict?

General, Pets Greatest wins our comparability as a result of its thorough protection, barely higher repute, and customization choices. Nonetheless, we all the time suggest getting a number of quotes from pet insurance coverage suppliers, so that you would possibly nonetheless take into account Nationwide too. And if quick reimbursement is essential to your monetary scenario, undoubtedly hold Nationwide in thoughts.

Pets Best logo

In the event you didn’t discover what you have been on the lookout for, our specialists dig even deeper into every firm in our particular person critiques of Pets Greatest and Nationwide.

General Winner: Pets Greatest

Our specialists have spent hundreds of hours researching to convey you our complete and continuously up to date pet insurance coverage critiques, together with our high picks and particulars on every of the preferred pet insurance coverage firms. We give awards for the most effective worth, multi-pet reductions, quickest declare processing, and finest newcomer. You’ll even see winners for unique pets and cats.

Sources: [1] NAPHIA

Tagged With: ,


Leave a Comment